About Trump and That Disabled Reporter

So, odds are good that you’ve heard about actress Meryl Streep’s speech the other night where she said politically charged things like “disrespect invites disrespect. Violence incites violence. When the powerful use their position to bully others, we all lose.” OK, that’s not quite a fair depiction of the matter. Her speech actually did constitute an attack on Donald Trump. I didn’t watch the it, but I heard about it in real time from friends on Facebook who felt like she was speaking for them.

At the same time, the speech was given from a very particular perspective – that of someone ensconced in the entertainment industry, a world which works rather differently than the world which the rest of us live in. I have some of the same criticisms of the content of the speech as Trevor Noah. (“Don’t make your point by shitting on someone else’s thing.”) Of course, there was the expected backlash from people who resented “being lectured” by a Hollywood celebrity. But those folks were by and large the same people who voted for a reality TV star for president, so they can really just stfu now.

Anyways, Streep’s speech highlighted an incident from 2015 in which Donald Trump apparently mocked reporter Serge Kovaleski’s physical disability. True to form, Trump has insisted that he did no such thing and that the media was just being mean and unfair. Streep’s speech has lead to a resurrection of videos claiming to prove that Trump did not actually mock a reporter’s physical disability, one of which I’ll embed below.

Now, clearly I and a good number of other people have decided that it is necessary to take an oppositional stance to Trump, but obviously we don’t want to become monsters ourselves in the fight. So it’s wise to actually look at the evidence from the other side in order to avoid being dishonest or unfair in ways that amount to being unjust. So, let’s look at the evidence against the claim that Trump mocked a reporter’s physical disability and evaluate it. (Trigger warning: video of Donald Trump, including audio of his voice. My sincere apologies.)

https://www.facebook.com/plugins/video.php?href=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.facebook.com%2FDonaldTrumpAmerica45%2Fvideos%2F981815025296933%2F&show_text=1&width=560

So here’s my take on the evidence, such as it is. First off, the mocking of the general from that same speech didn’t look remotely like the spastic display he put on when talking about the disabled reporter. The clip of him mocking Ted Cruz happened after Trump had already come under fire for apparently mocking a reporter’s disability and was probably him just creating cover for himself. The clip from 25 days before the incident in question bears only the vaguest resemblance to the incident in question. And the one from Larry King live (that they had to go back 11 years to find) is somewhat similar, but not nearly as animated as the incident in question. I’m thinking the fact that they have 3 clips from prior to the outrage, spanning over a decade’s worth of time is kind of the opposite of compelling evidence that Trump was not mocking a reporter’s disability.

However, even if we accept as an absolute fact that Trump occasionally imitates spasticity to mock people (including himself), there’s still the reality that a normal, decent person would not use that particular gesture to mock someone who actually suffers from spasticity. Ever. In fact, I’m pretty sure that people who suffer from spasticity would very much appreciate it if we’d stop using an imitation of their disability as visual short hand for “idiot”. If you really want to get down to it.

But even those of us who aren’t all that sensitive will still go out of our way not to create the appearance of mocking someone’s physical disability. And we’re horrified and embarrassed if we happen to do something which causes someone to think that we’re  mocking a person’s disability. It’s the sort of thing we have nightmares about doing. In fact, I knew a guy back in college who was born with a deformed arm and hand who would reach out to shake with that hand when he wanted to be a jerk just because he knew the person would be embarrassed by their own reaction. Because again, most of us put a lot of stock in the value of not appearing to make fun of someone’s physical disability.

So, did Donald Trump make fun of a reporter’s disability? I would say yes. But even if his defender’s arguments are 100% correct, the fact still remains that Donald Trump, true to form, does not behave anything like a normal, decent person behaves. Not even in situations with a really low bar like not using an imitation of spasticity when making fun of someone who suffers from spasticity. Duh.

Advertisements

5 thoughts on “About Trump and That Disabled Reporter

  1. Reblogged this on By the Mighty Mumford and commented:
    I RESPECT THIS DISCUSSION…IT’S NOT JUST ANOTHER
    HISSY FIT FROM A SPOILED, HATEFUL ACTRESS WHO CARES VERY LITTLE FOR HER FANS…BUT THIS BLOGGER I RESPECT FOR ACTUALLY GATHERING EVIDENCE WITHOUT A KNEE-JERK FLY OFF THE HANDLE. BRAVO, REBECCA TROTTER!!!!!

    Like

  2. Good post as always. I love how you rarely mince your words and are willing to consider others opinions in a reasonable manner. I am off FB now so am glad I can still read your stuff here.

    Like

  3. I admire your healthy insistence on examining the actual data. Nit-picking deniability is part of Trump’s stock in trade.

    But shouldn’t we be focusing our attention on his nominations, and, of course, his tax return? And in its own way, I fear that going on and on about the mocked reporter incident plays into Trump’s strategy presenting himself as a naughty boy with the guts to stand up to the liberal establishment. While we are playing tiddlywinks, Breitbart is playing chess.

    Like

    • I think what we’re doing is pulling threads on the support that Trump has. An issue like tax returns and financial dealings feels really huge to a lot of people. And they just assume that things work differently for very wealthy people, so whatever information the tax returns contains is likely to be written off as business as usual. But being unfairly judged is a very real, relatable issue that people can grasp onto. The thing is that Trump is getting a lot of support from people who have very little capacity to admit error. If you can push them into a corner on some minor point, having to admit error, even on something pretty minor, can sometimes cause the whole thing to start to come unraveled for them. And researchers have found that it’s much easier to get people to admit error in a way that leads to that unraveling when dealing with a relatively minor issue than with a great big huge issue. Besides, his tax returns were the subject of yesterday’s small action. So I’ve got ya covered. 😉

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s